Is Your Business Model Right for You?

This question is relevant to both new and established businesses…

Let’s assume an NP, perhaps you, is thinking about opening a practiceโ€ฆ

Are you focusing on finding the right space, choosing an EHR, getting credentialed, finding equipment, and more?

While these are big decisions, thereโ€™s one question that must be answered firstโ€ฆ

How will your practice provide care and bring in enough money to support you and the practice?

You have to answer this question first because many of the decisions you will make down the line will depend on it.

This is where the business model comes into playโ€ฆ

If youโ€™re an NP with an established practice, you may think worrying about your business model is a moot point.

But it may still matterโ€ฆ

If you’re busy with a full schedule but your practice isnโ€™t working as well as youโ€™d like, especially if you struggle to pay yourself or spend every evening catching up, it may be time to rethink your business model.

But firstโ€ฆ

A business model describes how a business creates, delivers, and provides value to its customers, and how it generates profit.

The definition is the same across all industries. It applies whether itโ€™s a restaurant, a software company, or a healthcare practice.

Every business needs customers who value what it offers; at the same time, the business must generate enough revenue to deliver that value.

Healthcare is somewhat unique. It adds some complexity because the person receiving care isnโ€™t always the one paying for it.

So, as an NP in private practice, your business model still shapes how your practice serves patients, meets their needs, and generates enough revenue to support that work, with one small additional consideration: who pays you.

Often, people assume the business model and the business plan are the same.

But thatโ€™s not the caseโ€ฆ

Ideally, the business model comes before the business plan; however, businesses donโ€™t always start that way. Often, someone has a product or business idea and runs with it.

The business plan describes how you will build and operate the practice based on the services you plan to offer and the population you want to serve.

Also, a business model is not to be confused with a legal structure, such as an LLC or corporation.

Your legal structure defines your personal liability, tax obligations, and who controls the business. It has nothing to do with the value you provide through your businessโ€ฆ taxes are due whether you sell services or widgets.

No, not all businesses start with a clear business model.

However, every business and practice has a business model, whether the owner deliberately chose it or followed a familiar example.

You donโ€™t need the labelโ€ฆ

However, you do need clarity about what you want to do and whether your choices will work well together.

Here’s an exampleโ€ฆ

Letโ€™s say you want your practice to offer longer appointments, same-day access, a low-fee structure, and pro bono care for individuals who can’t pay.

Your patients may value most of these goals, but your practice may not be able to support all of them. Because together, they require time and resources your revenue goals likely won’t support.

And without looking at the big picture, you may end up filling the gap with unpaid work.

Thinking through your business model and various scenarios helps determine what you can promise, how many patients you can serve, what staffing you need, and whether it is sustainable.

People often use โ€œbusiness modelโ€ to describe payment arrangements; while important, they’re only part of the picture.

For most practices, common approaches include:

Traditional Insurance-Based (fee-for-service):
The practice bills insurers for covered services and collects the patient’s applicable responsibility. Sustainability depends partly on reimbursement, collections, visit volume, and billing costs.

Cash-Only (Direct-Pay):
The practice doesnโ€™t accept insurance, and patients pay directly for individual visits or services. Here, fees must cover the services, and enough patients must be willing and able to pay.

Membership Model:
Patients, or sometimes employers, pay recurring, monthly fees for certain defined or unlimited services. Direct primary care generally replaces traditional insurance billing for those services. Membership revenue must support the care and access promised.

Concierge:
Patients pay a retainer for specified benefits or access, and practices may also bill insurance for covered services. This differs from the usual DPC arrangement.

Employer Contracts:
Here, an employer contracts and pays for defined healthcare services or access for employees. To be profitable and sustainable, the practice must price the agreement around the required workload and resources.

Hybrid Approaches.
Practices may combine revenue sources, such as insurance billing and separate direct-pay services; adding more options can increase the complexity.

How you deliver care, combined with your payment approach, shapes your practice.

In-office visits, telehealth, and home visits describe how you deliver care, while primary care, womenโ€™s health, and other areas of focus describe what you offer and whom you serve.

For example, an NP offering office and virtual womenโ€™s health visits could bill insurance, accept direct payment, or use a combination.

Each choice creates different costs, administrative requirements, and patient expectations.

Thatโ€™s why using descriptors such as โ€œvirtual practiceโ€ alone doesnโ€™t explain how the business earns money or whether it can support its owner over time.

Reviewing your business model can be especially useful once you have real experience and financial records.

Here are a few scenarios:

  • Perhaps your practice has grown, but your compensation hasnโ€™t.
  • You work too many hours and struggle to pay all bills.
  • Patients may need more between-visit support than you anticipated.
  • A service you added may consume substantial staff time while contributing little toward the bottom line.

Reviewing your business model can help you examine the assumptions behind those problems and help you find solutions.

Start with what actually happens:
Review your collections, expenses, visit patterns, and staff workload. Include your own time spent in addition to seeing patients.

Look for services or processes that are poorly supported by current revenue.

Identify what has changed:
Your patient population, costs, staffing, and personal goals may be different from when you first opened.

The model that was built around your willingness to work evenings and weekends may no longer work for you.

Identify and choose an adjustment:
You might adjust your schedule, improve collections, reconsider underused office space, or evaluate whether offering a particular service still benefits the practice.

However, before making any changes, review the potential impact the adjustment has on your patients and practice.

Track and Test:
Specify what the potential improvement should look like.

Whether it’s better owner compensation, less after-hours work, or more reliable cash flow, track patient experience and response alongside your financial results.

You may find that your current business model is sound, but that your execution needs improvement.

Alternatively, you may realize that working more efficiently won’t fix a fundamental mismatch between the value you provide and how you get paid.

Whether youโ€™re planning a practice or reviewing an established one, write down whom you serve, what you offer, how you deliver it, and how you get paid.

Then ask yourselfโ€ฆ

Does my current revenue support the total cost of providing those services, including paying myself enough?

Your business model should make good care possible and sustainable for your patients, your practice, and for you.


Join the conversation… leave your questions and comments below.


By Johanna Hofmann, MBA, MAc., regular contributor to the NPBusiness blog.

Leave a Reply


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}